7 Comments
User's avatar
Billy Suhr's avatar

Sounds like the original Charismatics, like many of their time, wanted to be like the Protestants. Looks like Charismatic Renewal and modernism are just liberal Protestantized Catholics.

Expand full comment
Michael H. Brown's avatar

apostles prayed as charismatics

Expand full comment
Billy Suhr's avatar

They were both Apostles and Bishops. Charismatics teach that ordinary lay people can do the things Apostles and Bishops do. Charismatics are wrong.

Expand full comment
Lisa Mary Crammer's avatar

This is a grave concern that I am grateful is made public

Expand full comment
NICK ALEXANDER's avatar

Did the book explain how the first modern mass occurrence of tongues began directly after Pope Leo XIII's prayer to the Holy Spirit (girded by St. Elena Guerra) on Jan 1 1901? Because linkings to Montanism is not very persuasive.

Expand full comment
Lisa Mary Crammer's avatar

Please check your text as I important information regarding this podcast

Expand full comment